Who is the better rugby player?

Question

just something 4 fun, who do you think is better and why?

Dan Carter or Carlos Spencer?

David Campase or Will Carling?

Wilko or Carter? (difficult one)

Answer 1

What?? You dare even contemplate comparing the legendary Dan-the-man-Mehts-taught-him-everything-... to that one trick Jaffa-ite show pony Carlos Spencer???? Wash your mouth out with soap.

Campo over Carling too BTW. :-)

Answer 2

I cannot believe that people have been saying Carlos is better than Dan Carter!!  The AB's had one of their LEAST successful era's when Carlos was playing five-eighth.  He was a great provincial and Super rugby player but never had the ability to control a test match like Carter does.

Campo over Carling any day of the Week or any other Pommie back....

I can't make a decision on Wilko or Carter.....

Answer 3

Carter/campesee/carter

Answer 4

Carlos

Carlos

Carlos

Answer 5

1. why Carlos of course!

2. Campese no comparison!

3. Neither theyre both playing like girls at the moment!

Answer 6

Dan Carter he has everything Carlos has plus he can kick goals.

Campase he had the best step in the game still does. and he didn't just rely on he speed to score tri.

wilko better under pressure

Answer 7

You have got to be kidding.Carter is an all round package for a first five eight.Spencer on the other hand is an all round disaster.Mehrtans was chosen over spencer at all costs a while back and i remember mehrtans getting less than 1 game for the crusaders when carter burst onto the scene.

Answer 8

Carlos Spencer is by far better than Dan Carter. Spencer is a legend.

Answer 9

Dan Carter or Carlos Spencer? mmm Im guna have 2 say Carlos Spencer...

Wilko or carter? y wilko of course...

Answer 10

Carlos'the king' spencer is better than daniel carter carter has already reached his best sadly he reached the apex of his ability two years ago and has been kept in the all blacks because they actually think he will reach that skill level again its funny the last world cup in sydney evrybody blamed carlos for our early exit yet nobody is blameing dan sissy  boy i like to kick the ball carter i wonder if its because hes a canterbury player or because hes a white boy  carlos spencer  created a new style of playing first five eight  instead of kicking for territory  Carlos launched attack raids deep inside his own half he created the double pump  the knee chip  and the spencer kick(the banana kick) he was something special carlos  dc is  just good because he plays with good people hes nothing special campo has it over will carling  and johno or dc well i dont really care they both just kick the ball

Answer 11

It is without a doubt me . When I play EA Sports Rugby 2002, I am actually REALLY good, no kidding.