Who is the better signing Robinho OR Berbatov?

Question

Both cost £30mill+

So who's better and who would you want up front for your team?

Answer 1

Robinho is a much better signing and you wud be much better off taking him on your team then berbatov

Both these players have been bought at insane prices, way above their values, becoz of the transfer deadline

Robinho will be the main striker on man city but berbatov will hardly play wid tevez and rooney -coz fergi like playin 4-4-2 or even 4-3-2-1

Robinho is also a much better player

Answer 2

berbatov right now but robinho will be better soon 1ce he gets into the rhythm of the epl style of play

Answer 3

robinho - more versatille and although he wont get 25 goals a season he will make that many if played up front with another decent striker.  

Answer 4

Robinho

Answer 5

berbatov!!

he has a proven track record in the premiership!!  robinho is relatively small and might have problems with the physical defenders in the premiership.

berbatov has scored 40+ goals in 2 seasons tottenham

robinho has scored 20+ in 3 season at madrid.

berbatov has a better goals to games ratio and i think he will continue to shine. i just think robinho will get knocked around by some of the bigger defenders in the league.

Answer 6

Robinho.

SAF must Sacrifice either Rooney or Tevez.

Answer 7

Berbatov is a proven Prem striker who actually wanted to join united so to me he better value.

Robinho isnt proven and wanted to join Chelsea not city, he joined them out of pure desperation to escape Madrid. I bet he couldnt name a single player for city.

To me i see his signing the biggest risk !! :)

Answer 8

robinho isnt even all that

i cant believe people think man city will make it top 4 with robinho

hello

he needs the links and the midfielders

every club had signings

Answer 9

Has to be Berbatov, better goal scorer and a lot stronger than Robinho, he will get 20+ goals this season because of the service he will get, Robinho will start well, get knocked about a bit then wish he was back in Spain.

Answer 10

Only time will tell though in my opinion its berba. Proven in the premiership and will mscore even more with hargreaves, carrick, scholes, etc feeding him. Well wait and see what Robinho is like but I think h**l look good but be bullied in a far more phisically demanding league.

Answer 11

Robinho is the better choice because he can play both in the midfield and striker.  Berbatov has a smaller range of positions that he can play.  On the other hand both of them have excellent attributes such as speed and accuracy, but it is ridiculous that anyone in the world is getting paid £30+ million to play a sport that they both love to play.

Answer 12

Robinho. He is faster and better than Berbatov. Berbatov has only vision but robinho has everything except defending