Who is the most OVERRATED team in AFL atm?

Question

my vote goes to CARLTON followed by ESSENDON.

Answer 1

Carlton...definitely...followed by Collingwood

Go Cats!!!!

Answer 2

Richmond - people are always saying how they could do an upset

Freo - they jus arnt consistent. 1 minute they r sayin they'll b in th GF next their near th bottom of th ladder!!! They were overrated at th beginning of th yr

Answer 3

Hawthorn they always promise so much and never deliver..

Answer 4

St Kilda. Their whole team can be summed up by Nick Riewoldt, could be the best in the league but just isn't.

Answer 5

fremantle or st kilda

Answer 6

Carlton? Don`t think so.

I would say Freo & St. Kilda. Promised a lot but havent delivered.

Ray, you reckon Freo have great colours?! I could not disagree more. Friggin purple & green? What were they thinking??

Answer 7

St.Kilda but I'm a St.Kilda supporter!

Answer 8

Port Adelaide & Carlton.

Answer 9

Defiantely Port adelaide...GO THE BLUES!!!

Answer 10

Collingwood

Freo

West Coast

How can Carlton and the Dons be overrated when no one expected anything from them in the first place. Everyone tipped Essendon to get the spoon and they finished two games outside the eight. How is that overrated?

Answer 11

How could you possibly say Carlton are over-rated?!  No-one rates them other than their most diehard fans.

I'm going with Freo.  A two team state, money shouldn't be a problem, great uniform (do like their colours), always seem to have some stars, have had an armchair ride and just never, ever seem to deliver.

Answer 12

By your VOTE , I have to say you are a very astute follower of the game.   CARLTON are basically little more than a disgrace, they  have thumbed their nose at other clubs and the AFL rules, for years,and now because of their past misdemeanors and current wooden spoon gatherig position, are being REWARDED, with recruits like Stevens Port Adelaide, and Australia's so called BEST player Judd. Obviously there is no justice in AFL footy !

Essendon I dont mind,  a good strong club , prepared to support those who 'support' the club, however it will take them along time,(years) to regain the marketing exposure they have LOST, after replacing Sheedy as coach !

Answer 13

sorry how can anybody say Carlton they have done nothing and nobody expects nothing GEEEEEEEEEEEEE!

title has to go to the Swannnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnies, if they win a game they are premiership favourites all of a sudden

Answer 14

Lol I think Essendon, Richmond and Carlton

Answer 15

the top 3 over-rated teams go to

- deff. Port Power that was 1 pathetic grand final, c'mon 163 -44

- West Coast Eagles

- Collingwood

Answer 16

West  Coast Eagles

Answer 17

Teams-

Port Adelaide

Fremantle

St Kilda

Coach - Terry Wallace

Bombers getting rid of Sheedy for Knights was pure genius. Get used to the cellar Bomber fans

Answer 18

I would say St Kilda, they have the players to succeed and win a Premiership, but failed to do so.They are over-rated by the media and by the so called footy experts.

Port Adelaide would come in second.

Answer 19

How long have they been saying 'St Kilda is on the verge of a flag'?

Answer 20

come on rogue-Carlton over-rated i don't think so,i mean we've been down the bottom for a good 5 years how over-rated could we be?over-rated would be pt Adelaide or even your mob who without Buckley,clement,lica will go backwards next year,wait and see :)