Who is the most over-rated player in League?

Question

I'm guessing it will come out of the halves so for the record my vote is Brett Finch.

Answer 1

the question was who is the most over rated player in League (thats rugby league sean you r****d) not who is playing the worst. Finch never gets big raps and some people would be mistaken for thinking that Anasta had retired or moved to England to play the amount of publicity he and the struggling Roosters have gotten over the last few years. The most over-rated player in Rugby League is by far Justin Hodges, he cant tackle to save himself and is constantly giving away penalties for high shots and is also ill-disciplined. The only reason he plays for Australia is because Wayne Bennett was coach for so long and the only reason he scores any tries is because he has a weird shimmy of a step and players like Darren Lockyer make him look good.

Answer 2

uh, what league...nba, nfl, mlb, nhl ???

Answer 3

Brett Kimmorley is the most over rated, because all he seems to do is kick the ball and throw hospital passes.

B. Sherwin would come a very good 2nd.

Answer 4

Brett Finch, Brad Fittler mad him look good at Easts, Braith Anasta, Tim Smith and Todd Carney

Answer 5

Brett Finch - he has played some origin matches, has had the experience but he sure ain't showing it in the eels matches (although he played well a few weeks ago)

Answer 6

before i would have said anasta but he has been playing well so i would have to pick gower,when he make a mistake (which is quite often)its a big one.  and seanynan we are talking about the real football,not that puffy padded up bunch of wanabe's you call gridiron,

Answer 7

Sony boy Williams

Answer 8

Try looking at the category sean!!!! yeah Finch is good but not as good as every1 makes out.

Answer 9

toss up between brett finch and tim smith both should have a stint in reserve grade