Who is the most overrated player in the AFL?

Question

Out of current players

Answer 1

Dale Thomas.

That was an easy question. He is about 1/16th as good as he thinks he is.

Answer 2

I have to say Anthony Rocca.  I just dont understand why Collingwood persist with him in the forward when he is always out played.

ps:  Cartlon is making Chris Judd look so overrated !!

Answer 3

Pav

Answer 4

I am A Swans supporter but Lewis Roberts Thompson Is Hopeless he should of stayed with Union where he belonged

Answer 5

NOT Ablett or Judd. They are both superstars. Judd's not fit atm and has had no preseason. But he is amazing. How quickly do people forget?

I would say ADAM GOODES. ffs he really isn't up there with the elite. How he one 2 brownlows is beyond me. Actually no it's not he played well in a very good Team which had lots of hard working players but no real superstars.

Dale Thomas also. He's a frontrunner, as many Collingwood players are. Looks a million bucks when they're thrashing a team and can be very good, but just watch when they're under the pump, HE GOES MISSING.

Answer 6

Mark Johnson, Jimmy Bartel, Matt Stokes and Gary Abblett Jnr. - Basically the whole Geelong team.

Answer 7

its gotta be dan kerr! his such a hothead!

Answer 8

I would have to say Adam Goodes when he won 2 BROWNLOW MEDALS, I mean come on people he is NOT THAT GOOD!

Gary Ablett and Bartel are great players and you wonder why Geelong are so good, it's because they have a extremely talented midfield, Stokes not included.

I also think that LLoyd is a bit overrated.

Answer 9

this year, Chris Judd and Matthew Lloyd

Answer 10

Chris Judd or Gary Ablett both players arnt that good a player.

Answer 11

Gary Ablett Jnr. is the most over-rated player. His dad is better. (no offense)

Answer 12

Alan Didak

Answer 13

A. Rocca

Answer 14

Pavlich, sure he can play well, but when it comes to kicking important/game winning goals he lets the team down.