Who needs this trade more? Would you do it if you were either team? If so, which and why?

Question

reg. league (1QB, 2RB, 1WR/RB, 2 WR, 1 TE, 1D, 1K) with backups at all positions:

The trade is basically Westbrook and Palmer for Reggie Wayne, Graham and Heath Miller

The Westbrook team has Brees, Hasselback and Eli as backup QBs (autodraft ftw). For RBs they have Kevin Smith, Lendale White and McGahee, but lacks in TE (only has Owen Daniels) and WR (Chambers and Curtis)

The Graham team has Braylon, Santana Moss and Wes Welker at WR and at RB they have AP, Julius Jones and Aman Green. They are pretty weak at QB (Kitna and Rivers).

What do you think, would you do this trade if you were the Graham team? How about the Westbrook team?

Answer 1

I actually think this is a pretty even trade.  I would most likely do it if I were either team.  It's one of those situations where it'll actually help out both teams to make the trade.

Answer 2

the westbrook team wins, and tel that team to trade hasselback or eli, the person who gets more is westbrook though