Who should I draft in my dynasty league rookie draft?

Question

Malcolm Kelly (Redskins) or Donnie Avery (Rams) ?

I already drafted Devin Thomas (Redskins), so drafting Kelly could be smart (one of the two should work out) or stupid (2 Redskins). Donnie Avery is somewhat of an unknown, but will fit nicely in St Louis. Some say he could challenge for Isaac Bruce's vacated position immediately.

Kinda unsure what I should do here...

Answer 1

If those are your only two choices, I'd stay with Avery. Thomas is more likely to work out than Kelly and Avery has enough raw ability to live up to the hype and win over that vacant position.

To guy above....what? Bruce was traded....how can he win over that spot? Either way, I like Avery more.

Answer 2

I like Kelly

Answer 3

Go for Kelly.  Having two Redskins on your team will not hurt you.  It may be a little tough come Washington's bye week, but by then, you will already be using the waver wire.  Plus, there is always the possibility for trades.  That is why I always take the best players available.  Besides, Bruce's position is not that of a #1 receiver.  You would not be getting that much with Avery.  I am also willing to bet that Isaac Bruce wins that spot on the team and will hold it until at least the first quarter of the season.  Good luck.

Edit:  Guy below, your right, Bruce was traded towards the end of last season.  My bad.  Still, Avery will not be a #1, 2, or 3 reciever for the Rams.