Who should I have as my 2nd Quarterback, Aaron Rodgers or Jake Delhomme?

Question

I have a choice...I had Rodgers then dropped him because they stated Favre was coming back to Green Bay now Rodgers is the def starter with Favre going to the Jets. Who will have the more productive season?

Answer 1

There has to be better out there.  I would stay away from Delhomme he's an injury liability.  Worst case, if he heats up he'll most likely be available.  

Answer 2

Delhomme. He led the Panthers to a super bowl. Plus, he has Steve Smith.

Answer 3

aaron rodgers because hes throwing the ball to donald driver, greg jennings, jordy nelson, and donald lee, and ryan grant i guess too and hes got protection from that great O-Line

Answer 4

Honestly Rodgers is probably more consistent if you ever seen him play late in the game, he sticks to short quick passes to move the ball down field. As a backup hes ok, plus you have to remember Delhomme has been frought with injury over the past few years, however he is a more experienced quarter back, and has Smith as a option down field, if hes healthy he will make a bigger impac then rodgers, but thats only if hes healthy. Personally Id go with the bigger risk and take Delhomme.

Answer 5

Aaron Rodgers way better

Answer 6

Take Garcia

He's fairly consistent, runs a bit, and doesn't have the injury concerns that Delhomme has from Tommy John surgery.

Delhomme is more valuable than Rodgers, based mainly on the facts that he's a veteran, and Rodgers is essentially a rookie QB.

Rookie/first time starters commit a lot of turnovers their first year.

I wouldn't consider Rodgers for more than an emergency start.  Garcia and Delhomme when healthy are good enough to start with some regularity in favorable matchups (like Atlanta).

Answer 7

jake delhomme, he's going to have a great year

Answer 8

If Delhomme stays healthy this year, he's a stud at QB. He put up really good numbers last year and with Steve Smith around, he'll have the same numbers. Rodgers might be a safer pick because of Delhomme's injury issues, but I'd gamble with Delhomme.

Answer 9

You should go with Aaron Rodgers, Jake Delhome is an injury waiting to happen. You should see positive results out of Rodgers this year.