Who should I keep in my keeper leauge?

Question

I am in a fantasy football league where I get to keep 2 players from my last season team. My team wasn't very strong but I do have a few options. I have already chosen to keep Marion Barber but I am not sure who the other one will be, Devin Hester or Brandon Marshall. Let me know who you think I should keep and why. Thank you in advance!!

Answer 1

Barber (duh)

Answer 2

Brandon Marshall is a top WR. He'll get huge stats this year. The only reason Devin Hester is known to people is because he's a great return man. He has never proven himself at WR and also has a horrible QB (Grossman or Orton).

There is no doubt. You absolutely no doubt HAVE to take Bradon Marshall.

Answer 3

If those are your only other choices, I would go with Marshall.  He is a good receiver who will haul in over 80 yards a game.  With so many teams keeping the ball away from Hester, he's not guaranteed to bring you many points.  Fantasy football is about consistancy throughout the season.  Hester is too big of a risk from week to week, even though he has big play capability.

Answer 4

You should list out your team so we can better advise you.

Answer 5

I'm hoping you have other options. if so post them or e-mail me because neither Hester or Marshall equal a 2nd round pick. you need to look at keepers like they are draft picks. you are in a 2 player keeper which is rounds 1 & 2 of a draft. Barber is a late 1st round pick do you have anyone else that would go in the 1st or 2nd round? possibly a RB?

Answer 6

Ouch, that's a bad problem to have. If your second and third best players are Devin Hester and Brandon Marshall you're in trouble already. Consider those your first 2 draft picks. If you got through the first 2 rounds of the draft and you had Marion Barber and Devin Hester/Brandon Marshall, it's safe to say you're not where you want to be.  But I agree with these people, keep Marshall.