Who should I take at this spot?

Question

im in a dynasty football league and we are doing a redraft because this is our first year. I have the 11 pick overall and Im taking McFadden who should I take in the second round? I want to take 2 rbs. Players that will be around are... Larry Johnson, Maurice Jones -Drew, McGahee, Ryan Grant. those will be the best ones left.

Answer 1

I'd bet McFadden won't be around at 11 in a keeper draft

Answer 2

I say go with Ryan Grant.  He started mid season last year and rushed for almost a thousand yards in 9 games.  He is a pass catching RB and has ran several big plays over 20 yards.  With Brett Favre gone, the Packers have opted to switch to a running offense until Aaron Rodgers gets settled into the starting position.  If you have seen him run, then you will know that his ability is mind blowing.  That would be my pick.

Larry Johnson is a good pick, but aging line and only averaged 3.6 yards per carry.  Not the same LJ from 2005 and 2006.

MJD is a great option, but he shares the backfield.

McGahee is a good option, but with questions at QB for the Ravens, the running game may hurt with defenders stuffed at the line.  The QB situation is sad and pathetic with Kyle Boller at the helm.

Thumbs up to those who agree.

Answer 3

Jones-Drew hands down at this point, and just to open your thoughts some more, Moss would be nice to have if you want to go wide reciever

Answer 4

why did you take mcfadden ahead of barber or romo? thats just dumb. Mcfadden could have fell to your next pick.

Answer 5

I think Maurice Jones-Drew is a good pick at that spot. Other than him I would take Willis McGahee unless Ryan Grant proves that he isn't a one year wonder like Samkon Gado was a few years back.