Who should be my backup QB? Kitna or Rodgers?

Question

I have Peyton Manning starting, but I would like to have a backup for him.

who would be the better backup? Kitna or Aaron Rodgers?

Answer 1

Either  one, probably Kitna with more  upside

Answer 2

Jon Kitna is a bust and green bay has a much better o line and receivers.

Donald Driver and Greg jenning are much better then roy williams and Calvin johnson.

Answer 3

Kitna   he is proven   rodgers has never started

Answer 4

Kitna is a proven vet with two proven Wrs in Roy Williams and Mike Furrey and an emerging supersat in Calvin Johnson.  Although the pass-happy offense of Mike Martz is gone, you can bank on the Lions having to pass a lot due to the fact they will be playing from behind and have virtually no running game.  Rodgers is a gamble.  His team will be better, but fantasy football is NOT about team success.

Answer 5

aaron rodgers

only because detroit doesnt really have balance