Who should i keep? Rudi or Earnest?

Question

We keep 4 in out keeper league.... i know im keeping: Big Ben, Plaxico, and anquan boldin.... i need to know whether to keep Rudi Johnson or Earnest Graham, i know neither are great but thats all i have...

Im kinda leaning toward Rudi, because Earnest has Cadilac and Warrick coming back... what do you think? back up with facts/opinions.

Answer 1

A toss up at this point. If it costs you any extra, like a higher round draft pick, just go with whoever is "cheaper" for you to keep.

Rudi supposedly is back, healthy and has added about 15 pounds of muscle for this season.

Graham was great last year as a fill in but will have to share with Caddy and Warrick this year.

Both are roughly the same age, Graham is a touch younger and has less wear and tear on him.

Answer 2

Earnest is the better back of the 2.

~G{}{}d Luck!~

Answer 3

just to say i don't like pitt. I am a bengal fan and i will say that Rudi is the worst RB we have. He is a starter as of now but keep in mind that he has kenny watson, kenny irons(if hes healthy) and i think perry too. All are better than him. Cadillac hasen't done much and if u mean Warrick Dunn he is a beast. But, he is also getting old.

Answer 4

rudi

Answer 5

I'd keep rudi, but it's a tough one