Who should i take with the first rookie pick in my Football league?

Question

has to be a rookie, im thinking Stewart over McFadden because McFadden is so upright and Stewart is in a better situation

Answer 1

I would go with stewart. He has a better situation with Steve Smith getting all the attention. Hey how bout you rate my teams. I posted three of them.

Answer 2

matt  forte  for  the  bears  i  would  take  as  first  rookie  with  benson  on  the  sauce  bus  he  could  get  most  playing  time

Answer 3

I agree w/Fantasy King.  Gotta go with value at #1. Take McFadden, then try to deal him for Stewart/Forte/K. Smith/C. Johnson and something else.  No telling who's gonna be the best of them all IMO.  They're all in situations that could go either way (Mcfadden's got Fargas, Stewart's got DeAngelo, Forte's got the Chicago offense, Smith's got Detroit's unpredictability, Johnson's got L White & C Henry, Mendenhall's got Parker).  

If you're stuck with McFadden, you still have a shot, but if you can add another piece by dealing him, go for it.

Answer 4

I'd go with Stewart too, but if you have a lower pick than get forte or a receiver

Answer 5

you could either go with mcfadden who is clearly the best one . But he has alot of other Rbs on that team.

Or you could go with KEvin SMith. He is the only RB available on that team other than Tatum bell, but he won't be doing much at all. So he will get alot of touches.

I'd go with McFadden just off of pure talent.

Good Luck

Answer 6

personally i like mendenhall he on some draft boards was higher than mcfadden and willie parker did just get injured

but if you can trade down and get mendenhall that would be good

Answer 7

I would take McFadden and then trade down for Stewart and someone else. I think Stewart is going to do better?

Answer 8

Mcfadden without question or hesitation. for better or worse Davis will want to see the boy run this year.

He may be the second coming of sweetness or ran to death like houstons Earl Campbell.

time will tell.