Who should retire?

Question

Who should retire and why?

Me first:

There are a few obvious ones. But here's one from left field.

Peter Bell from the Dockers

He does not even train with the team. If he's got other interest then make a choice.

Answer 1

Yeah, I thought he was going to retire last year after it was reported he flew his parents up to Adelaide to watch the last game of the season in round 22 which he doesn't normally do.

Robert Harvey

David Neitz

Fraser Gehrig

Shaun McManus

Jason Laycock - delisted won't play again

Answer 2

I like to see champions retire on top of their game not one season too long aka Gehrig

Shane Crawford's my nomination still playing good footy and his team has a real chance in September would be the best way to bow out

Answer 3

I reckon everyones got it covered except one..

Mark "CHOCCO" Williams

Answer 4

Chris Tarrant, I can't ever recall a player getting so bad so quickly. Unless he can dramatically improve he should look elsewhere for a living.

Answer 5

chris judd......joking.....rob harvey, Micky O'Loughlin, scott west, peter bell, dustin fletcher, mark williams, michael gardiner....thinking of more....oh yeah both carr brothers, tredrea, brogan, .............

Answer 6

At the end of the year i think these players will

Mark Johnson

Peter Bell

David Neitz

Robert Harvey

David Wirrapunda

Joel Bowden

Micheal O'Louglan

Scott West

Answer 7

shane crawlford

brad johnson

Answer 8

big fraser gehrig wouldn't be far away now.the herald sun vote thing today was should david neitz retire, so him too, wakelin at collingwood is just about done too.

Answer 9

yer maybe peter bell should and i think shan crawfood and robit harvey casue his isn't as fast and as skillful any more

Answer 10

David Neitz.

Answer 11

The g-train and toby thurstans. Everytime Toby gets the ball he turns it over, he mezwell play for the opposition.

Answer 12

Davis Neitz, Robert Harvey, Shane Wakelin, Russel Robertson, Peter Bell, Joel Bowden and Fraiser Gehrig

Answer 13

They should retire the whole Melbourne football club

Answer 14

Ok, well i'll give you the obvious, Robert Harvey, also somthing which noone will expect but is for the better, Barry Hall of the Swans, Halls had his share, it is time for the new guys too show how they can shine. Can he sneak in his fourth Grand Final chance.

It's time to go BARRY HALL ! ! !

Answer 15

The umpire who bounced the ball from the centre into the Kangas forward 50....

Barry Hall - he should get back into the boxing ring where he belongs...

Answer 16

Shaun McManus

Matthew Carr

Peter Bell

Lance Franklin (Joking)

Darren Glass

Matt Lloyd should be going in a couple of seasons (out of form)

Robert Harvey

Barry Hall

Michael O'Loughlin

Brad Johnson

Trent Croad

Jimmy Bartel (Kidding)

Maybe Chris Tarrent

Nigel Lappin

Believe it or not I don't think anybody has thought of the Irish man Tadgh Kennelly!!!!! He should be going back to Ireland in a couple of years to play Gaelic Footy (Not my opinion he actually is)

Answer 17

idk i guess Peter Bell after you said that

Answer 18

peter bell is play some good football for a guy who is not training with the team dont you think

Answer 19

I can only think of 2.  Terry Wallace and Andrew Demetriou.  I think Terry's had enough chances to win a flag and Andrew's choice of knocking back Tasmania to join the AFL in favour of rugby dominated states like QLD and NSW shows a complete lack of vision.  It will never be a truly national comp until all states are involved.

Answer 20

Bell and Neitz is retiring at the end of this season

Answer 21

Neitz cos he is starting to embarrass himself, he cant play any more.

Barry Hall cos everyone hates him and he spoils the game.