Who thinks Carmelo Anthony Is Underrated?

Question

carmelo been my fav player for a while now since he came in the nba and i think that he is very underrated cuz of watched most of his games.. if you are an experienced melo fan give an answer to this.. is carmelo anthony underrated please be truthful thank you i will give best answer to best answer

Answer 1

hes very overrated.  he cant defend and isnt a leader.

Answer 2

dont get mad but i think the melow man is overrated,,

yes he is a very good offensive weapon but offense alone doesn't win championships, he is not a good leader and for his size, he should rebound more.. and should share the ball better



look at lebron, he is way way ahead than melo...

Answer 3

he is a underrated player, he has great moves to score. his defense is a little lacking, but when he does give a defensive performance, he is overlooked as being a ball hog. also he won a championship in Syracuse, in college ball you need a lot of D to win, so yea

Answer 4

The year he was drafted make things difficult for him. But I think LeBron and D-Wade are much better than him. Carmelo can be a franchise player if he decides to grow up. But he has talents in All-Star level. I think he gets what he deserves.

Answer 5

He plays no defense, The only thing he would win is a DUI race. He plays absolutely no D. The only reason Camby got the DPY because he gets to do weak side help on Melo's man. He's even worse on offense. He stops the ball to give Jaw dropping move that seem impossible to go in, but they score on the other end with half the effort. He stops the ball and does not provide any semblance of a smooth offensive flow(might be the fact that all players of the Nugs are one on one artist with no understanding of team play) So, No I don't think he is underrated in fact he is over rated

Answer 6

I think he's fine right where he is...

He is a VERY, VERY TALENTED player...If he doesn't have injury problems he will end up as a Hall of Famer...

With that said. He has his problems...he is a bad leader, and he jacks up lots of shots...then again, some of the best players jack up shots...

A great player with a bad attitude.

Answer 7

Stop the Melo DUI already. Kobe got caught raping, how come no one said S**t about that. Melo's a bad leader on the court, and a not very good defender, but he's can score in bunches a lot of occasion.

Answer 8

he is overrated, he cant defend and he cant lead a team. lookn at the playoffs. he gave up with iverson. ppl overhype as a superstar while, u saw him in the 2008 playoffs.he is a great, but not a superstar