Who to start? Brees or McNabb for week 1?

Question

I believe Brees will have a awesome year, but as far as week one goes it appears McNabb has the easier defense to go against. What do you think?

Brees vs Tampa Bay

McNabb vs Rams

Answer 1

That's a hard one. Drew Brees will be working with a fully healthy roster but coming off a hurricane evacuation. McNabb will be playing the easy defense of the Rams but doesn't have all the options that Brees does.  

Answer 2

I would go with Brees, Tampa has a alright defense but the Pass defense is not good. McNabb will have a good game but with his WR's hurt you are taking a risk.  

Answer 3

McNabb virtually always starts off HOT while Brees at least last season it took him awhile to get HOT. Even if you know Brees is better you definitly start McNabb because yes he plays the easier DEF and if McNabb stays healthy he would be back to elite QB like he was when they had the 4 straight years of being in the NFC champ game and then the SB the 4th year. He had TO for a year only. So the first 3 years were with almost no one at WR. So again McNabb should start week 1.