Who to start?clevelands Derek Anderson or jacksonvilles David Garrard?

Question

if you had the choice to start one or the other who would you choose?

Answer 1

id say anderson normally but he is coming off a concussion. so maybe it might take him a week or so to get comfortable? Garrard is solid, not a super star but you know what your going to get with him. Id go with anderson unless you hear reports of him missing out on practices or still dinged up, etc.

Answer 2

Anderson.

The reason for this is that Clevelands passing offense is going to generate more scoring touchdowns and more passing yards.   Anderson will probably throw more interceptions, but h**l throw enough TDs and throw for enough yards that it will more then make up for the difference and then some.

Garrard isnt going to sink you, but his receiving corps just isnt that great, and the Jags still depend on the running game.

Answer 3

Anderson looks to be in a shootout with Dallas this week.  But I wasn't impressed during the preseason and there are injury concerns.  

Garrard has a division game vs. Tennessee and everyone is healthy.

Do you want guaranteed 10-12 pts or take a chance with Anderson and have a shot at 30?  Personally, I'd go with Anderson, but its a gamble.

Check out my fantasy site http://sites.google.com/site/fantasyfoot...