Who was he talking about?her or me??

Question

me and my crush were talking about who liked who (lol dont ask i was bored) and it was soccer practice and we were all sticky and sweaty, but anyways, i said "so do u like that new girl, amy?" and he said "who's that?you mean that fat girl who likes me?" and i was shocked..i think he knew i liked him and i just turned around and i wanted to cry...im not fat, im totally average (i checked it in BMI) was he talking about me?or was did he really mean another girl?i know he doesnt know who amy is cuz he doesnt know her...but i actually started to think he liked me!when i asked when practice was he immediately said (and i wasnt talking to him btw) "its on blah blah blah...(you know.im not giving out details)and i said thanks and then he asked to borrow my phone and stuff....but was he really talking about me or someone else?i mean there's this other kind of fat girl who's really really nice..and i dunno..am i jumping to conclusions?TELL ME THE TRUTH..dont give me an answer to make me feel good.

btw, im 5'4 and 117 lbs...is that fat for me?

Answer 1

he was talking about the other girl. unless you were talking about yourself in third person, and your name is amy.

besides, your weight is fine. i think it's perfect. so good for you.

and i'm not the kind of person who would lie to make someone feel better. if you asked any of my friends then you'd get the same answer.

-edit- i'm sorry. jeez. i didn't see the details when i posted. take a chill pill.

Answer 2

i think he was talking about someone else........~xoxo ally*

Answer 3

you aren't fat and I'm pretty sure he was talking about the other girl

you are wayyy over analyzing this.

If he DID call YOU fat (which i really doubt is what was happening) he's a jackass anyways.. ! :)

Answer 4

hes obviously talking about the fat girl named amy who likes him..

why would he be talking about you?

that makes no sence.

and no your not fat.  

Answer 5

5'4'' and 117 is not fat at all...your question kind of confuses me who is amy are you amy? you were talking to  him so he wouldn't say that to your face ahhhhhh i am so confused?????

Answer 6

your not fat babe... check out the cdc bmi calculator to find that out for yourself.  Its simple but effective

Answer 7

maybe there is a new fat girl that like shim and he thinks her name is amy but it really isnt. and btw how could amy have ANYTHING to do with you? i seriously doubt he wudda said that a girl named amy was fat when he was talking about you. guys arent smart enough to come up with things like that. they say what they think so he must think some new fat girl that likes him is amy. and BTW he would have to be blind to think ur fat. i mmean do u seriously think ur fat? u sound somewhere bewtween skinny and average sooooo dont worry. hope i helped

Answer 8

why would he mean you if you were talking about another girl?

Answer 9

it sound like he was talking about amy, cuz thats who you were talking about, i dont see how he could possible be talking about you. im only 4'11'' and i am 120 lbs, you are skinny girl!

Answer 10

No u r not fat and no he wasn't talking about u guyz don't call a girl fat to her face unless he's in like 5th grade or sumtin but even if he was he wud be blunt and say "ur fat"

Answer 11

Ok.

1. Don't let a boy make you feel self concious. You are NOT FAT.

2. The boy wasnt talking about you.  If you were talking about some other new girl, thats what he was talking about. It had nothing to do with you.

3. If he would dare say "the fat girl that likes me?" he must not be a nice guy.  Thats so rude of him.  You seem really nice and you desrve better than that.

-Courtney

Answer 12

you're DEFINITELY not fat. i don't think he was talking about you, unless your name is also amy because you said the name of the girl. but im not so sure that you would want to be friends with this guy because he was such a jerk about whoever he was talking to. that's not really someone who's fun to hang out with, much less go out with because he might not be a supportive bf.

Answer 13

What i dont get it? You  said you were talking to him and he said who's that?you mean that fat girl who likes me?" and then you said you turned around and was about to cry..  are you amy? Why would you talk in thrid person? I dont get it and what other girl? WHAT?

Answer 14

this is ridiculous, why would he say that to your face if you asked him about someone else?  You're just being paranoid, just keep talking to him and if he doesn't like you then he isn't interested.

Answer 15

yeah thats a normal weight. and I would be shocked too but not because I thought he was talking about me but about that other girl like that. I don't think its u. but is amy fat because maybe he does know her? Maybe he was tlkaing baout another fat girl that he thought he recognized the name. your name isnt amy is it? lol no i think your fine. i dont think he was tlaking about u