Who was the better goalie - Daniel Berthiaume or Pokey Reddick?

Question

Which of these two legendary goaltenders, who comprised perhaps the greatest Jets netminding combo outside of Soetaert-Staniowski, would you choose?

Answer 1

Tight call they where a great team but solo each stumbled.

I'd say Berthy....

Answer 2

Eldon had the better glove hand, and looked far better in a white suit than Ray Emery ever will.

Are you those two tandems are better than Mattsson/Hamel?

Answer 3

Thanks for the memories !!  I grew up in Winnipeg in the 80's/90's and that was a cool cool time.  As for you're question, I think Pokey was slightly better than the Bandit, but it was undoubtably one of their top goaltending duos, if not the best.  As for the answerer who mentioned Bob Essensa, I can still hear Kurt Kielback (sp?) calling the play, "Essensa the save! "

Answer 4

eldon for sure.

Answer 5

what about Bob Essensa? but if i have to pick between the 2 i would say pokey would be the better. he has a cup and the better nickname.