Who will Yanks get first: Jason Bay, or Xavier Nady?

Question

both are good right handed bats, and both play left field. which one will go to Yanks first (if either one)??

Answer 1

nady.

Answer 2

nady

Answer 3

Jason bay is having a decent year this year, so i think that the asking price may be a little steep. But either way the yanks will go out and get one of these guys and maybe a lefty out of the bullpen from the pirates like Grabow.. Kinda like the Abreu and Lidle trade a few years ago.

Answer 4

The Yankees are only getting one or the other..I think they're getting Bay.  I don't think the Yanks want to pay the high price the Pirates are probably asking for Nady

Answer 5

The only way the Pirates are going to trade Bay is if they are overwhelmed with prospects. Nady, on the other hand, can be had for one top line prospect plus one mid-level prospect. But to correct you, Nady has not played LF this year (RF & 1B), and probably would require a major adjustment.