Who will have a better season: Aaron Rodgers or Donovan McNabb?

Question

Who will have a better season: Aaron Rodgers or Donovan McNabb?

Answer 1

If he stays healthy McNabb. He was amazing two years ago before he got hurt.

Answer 2

It's funny everyone keeps saying who will Mcnabb throw to. Besides TO for one year; he's never had any WR's to throw to, and when healthly has always put up great numbers and more importantly won games.

Now he does have the best pass catching RB in the league, which takes a lot of pressure off the WR's. Health is the question for Mcnabb, if he stay healthly all season he'll be in the probowl.

Rodgers has so much pressure on him right. He seems to be handling it pretty well, but as soon as the Packers lose a couple games in a row it's going to get really bad for him. I think he'll do ok, but I don't think he's a franchise QB.

Answer 3

donovan...

Answer 4

ima say donovan, but basically i think its a tossup at this point

Answer 5

AROD  

Answer 6

I would say Aaron Rodgers

Answer 7

This may be the easiest question I have ever answered.

McNabb is the 2nd best QB in the NFC.

Rodgers will be injured by week 4.

Answer 8

I would say Donovan McCain  

Answer 9

My thoughts tell me that Rodgers will have a better season because he has more weapons. Who can McNabb throw the ball to?

Answer 10

mcnabb

he doesn't have all the pressure and has a lot of experiance also having a running back like westbrook who is also a good reciever will help him have a better season.

Answer 11

it comes down to the team overall and i will say rogers does because of the depth he has at receivers and a healthy ryan grant, but he will throw alot of picks because he is inexperienced but i think he will have a better season

Answer 12

McNabb is my pick. He's still an elite player; and Rodgers is going into his first season as a starter.

Isn't it odd that McNabb is a great QB and he lacks "star quality" receivers; and Rodgers is an unknown (for the most part) that has excellent receivers??