Who wins this Slugfest?

Question

Two once undefeated fighters young, strong, and determined to get their titles back. But in a fight of young lightweights who would win this all out war, micheal katsidis or Juan Diaz, diaz lost his last fight to nate cambell and Katsidis lost his too casmayor. Both fighters like to fight in and brawl but with katsidis the bigger puncher and diaz the more active fighter and great chin, who would win, Micheal Katsidis or Juan Diaz?

Answer 1

Katsidis lost to a truly "great" fighter, Casamayor is in my opinion clearly a legitimate hall of famer.  Juan Diaz lost to a solid veteran in  Campbell, and I like Nate but Cambell has never reached the level that Joel Casamayor operated at most of his career.  Joel has been one of the elite of the lower divisions since before he defected from Cuba, and I hold him in the highest esteem.  He is the last of his era, his contemporaries have faded, but he remains elite.  His victory over Katsidis, a younger stronger prospect gives new life to Joel's already successful career.  If life was just, Casamayor would land a million dollar pay day against Pacquiao or another name fighter and retire in comfort in Cuba or were ever he chooses.  I wish him only the best and truly hope it works out for him.  Cambell is a grandfather, and he out worked Diaz to earn the respect of the boxing community.  Nate also, if life was just would turn his success against Diaz into a retirement fund, and he too has my best wishes.  

I think Diaz has more skill than Katsidis, but Diaz showed in the Cambell fight that he may choose not to employ the tools he has.  The loss to Cambell was has big an upset as boxing as seen in recent years.  Katsidis took a serious step up fighting Casamayor, and the age factor worked in his favor, unfortunately for the youngster, Casamayor was not your average middle aged boxer.  It happens sometimes.  I give the edge to Diaz over Katsidis, the "baby Bull" has the experience edge over the Australian.

Answer 2

Micheal Katsidis I think would win , Diaz is more skilled and they both defintly have a lot of heart and apply a lot of pressure in their fights. But Katsidis has a big edge on power and it seems when Jaun Diaz gets hurt or cut he starts to slow down a bit , where Katsidis only fights at 1 pace .. coming forward no matter what. I think eventualy that would be too much for  Diaz to handle.

Answer 3

I go with juan Diaz, not because thats my last name, but i beliebe he has more skills than mick. But who knows both are determine & hungry for a win.

Answer 4

diaz