Who wins this TOSS UP battle between "BABY" Joe Mesi of 2003 vs Donovan "RAZOR" Ruddock of 1991?

Question

Who wins this TOSS UP battle between "BABY" Joe Mesi of 2003 vs Donovan "RAZOR" Ruddock of 1991?

Answer 1

the ruddock of '91 went 12 rounds with mike tyson, who has mesi fought during his 11 years as a pro? if he wants to break marciano's record, he's cheating because the rock fought the best of this day.

razor takes this by 4th round stoppage.

Answer 2

Joe Mesi is undefeated and that is a great accomplishment, but he has not fought what you would consider top notch competition.  Ruddock to his credit fought the best possible opponents he could face and was once a feared heavyweight because of his punching power.  I believe that Ruddock would knock Mesi out in 9 rounds of a good hard fought fight.

Answer 3

Id go with that, except the rounds. I dont think Mesi could survive THAT long.

Razor Ruddock had bad timing. He came along during a pretty competitive time in the heavyweights. Mike Tyson, Holyfield, Riddick Bowe, Lennox Lewis...to name a few.

Joe Mesi....well he excites his little hometown. But honestly if he even considered fighting a REASONABLY sized heavyweight...he would get trashed.

I wouldnt even give Joe Mesi 8 rounds against James Toney...he would be outskilled.

Joe Mesi is a good contender...but thats all.