Who wins this trade?

Question

Joe Addai

Derrick Mason

for

Andre Johnson

Chris Chambers

Earnest Graham

No point per catch

Answer 1

whoever has addai....i wouldn't trade him for anything cuz he will have a big year this season

Answer 2

Ya. Whoever got Addai wins this trade. Whenever you give up a stud halfback you must get one in return.  Don't think that happened in this trade,

Answer 3

I would say the one who gets Addai.  He is a top 5 RB.  Always trade many for 1, not 1 for many.  I would assume that the 1 trading Johnson, Chamber and Graham already have a premier WR, so absorbing Mason is not a problem.  The team getting the 3 players would have to need to have open spots in order to play these players.  Don't worry about trading to bolster your bench.  A great bench scores 0 points.  Addai will get a lot of looks from Peyton in the passing game, and should be posting great numbers running as D's will not be able to stack the box against the Colts potent offense.

Answer 4

Definetly the one that gets Andre, Chris, and Earnest. Andre Johnson is gunna be great this year cuz of Matt Schwab. Chris Chambers is underated i think. He's very physical, gets good yards after catch. Earnest Graham.... we all saw what he did last year.  

Answer 5

whoever has addai, he is going to be HUGE this year.