Who won this trade Part One?

Question

It took me about two hours of negotiating but here is the trade I came up with.

I give up

Andre Johnson

Chris Chambers

Selvin young

Matt Schaub

I get

Joe Addai

Derrick Mason

David Garrad

Drew Bennett

Answer 1

Very close trade.  I don't know if I'd do it.

Answer 2

you did cause only good person you gave up is

andre johnson

then on the other hand

look

you got addai

hes gonna get better this year

then david garrad looking to win bout 9 games

he will be useful if you dont got back up quarterback

then the rest are bunch on bullcrap that you dont need