Who would be a decent #3 RB?

Question

I need to start one more with AP and Addai:

Deuce McCallister - NO

Sammy Morris - NE

Rashard Mendenhall (R) - PITT

Jamaal Charles (R) - KC

Answer 1

McCallister or Mendenhall

Answer 2

Mendenhall all the way. Just pray to God that he can produce as a 2nd string RB behind Willie Parker with all the hype that surrounded him during the draft and preseason.

Deuce is breaking down and gets hurt a lot now. Sammy Morris won't have enough touches since Maroney's already there and the Pats don't run that often. Charles well.. he could be playing in CFL 4 years time or be a backup journeyman.

Answer 3

those are all back ups pretty much...they all stink equally!

but if i had to pick one, i'd go with mendenhall although he fumbles a lot.  That's a tough one...Charles won't see the light of day with Larry friggin Johnson in KC.  Sammy Morris doesn't get many touches with Maroney and Reggie Bush is poised for a break out season plus Deuce has been breaking down the past few years similar to Rudi Johnson and Shaun Alexander.  

Just keep an eye on the waiver wire...that's a tough choice...

Answer 4

I guess McCallister.  I wouldn't want any of them to tell you the truth. Mendenhall would be my next choice.

Answer 5

Rashard, hes the 3rd down and power back behind willie. or maybe duece if you want. But i'd get Rashard  

Answer 6

Of those 3, I'd go Deuce.  He will see more carries than the others.

Check out my fantasy site http://sites.google.com/site/fantasyfoot...

Answer 7

duece, bush is too small to last the whole year

Answer 8

How did you manage to get AP and Addai? A 6 team league??? Then you need to start one of these scrubs???? With AP and Addai, does it really matter who else you start?

I'd go with R. Mendenhall, it will be him and Parker touching the ball where the others you listed will have 3 guys sharing carries.

By the way, who are your QB's Brady and P. Manning? Have Randy Moss and R. Wayne as your starting WRs.........

Answer 9

You've got to go with Deuce. While he might not be 100 percent, he will get the start and more carries than the other guys. It's got to be tempting to plug Mendenhall in, but I'd wait a week or two to see what his role is going to be in the Pittsburgh offense. Deuce is the safest best. Good luck!