Who would get the better end of this trade?

Question

Peyton Manning, Marion Barber, and Anquan Boldin

FOR

Tony Romo, Brian Westbrook, and Marvin Harrison

Answer 1

that's a tough one, i would have to see the rest of your team to make the best choice. If you need help at RB then the 2nd one is better, help at QB, the 1st one is better. WR, flip a coin, both are good but Harrison is old and Boldin though very fast has problems with ball control.

Answer 2

Well, Manning is nursing a bad knee, although he should be ready to play by the opener.

Romo is healthy and has a ton of weapons that are hungry for success this season. Plus he has the mobility Manning doesn't.

Barber is going to be an animal this season. He will split carries with Felix Jones, but still will get the red zone carries and have the most success.

Westbrook is also a great fantasy RB, so you are even in that catagory.

Boldin is in a contract dispute with the Cardinals and requesting a trade. He is very unhappy and the Cards say they will not trade him. So if he does play, he won't be very motivated.

Harrison is motivated, but his knees are the big question mark to whether he will have the same abilities he had before the injury.

So, to me, the guy getting Romo, Westbrook and Harrison wins this trade.

Answer 3

whoever gets Manning Barber and Boldin.  Still, this trade is pretty even overall, because the 2nd team throws in Westbrook.

Answer 4

the guy getting peyton manning, Marion barber, and Boldin is getting the better end of that trade

Answer 5

Peyton Manning, Marion Barber, and Anquan Boldin

Answer 6

Going by their stats from last year Romo, Westbtook, and if Harrison can regain his form would be the better deal in my opinion. however, it really is an almost even deaal considering the questions marks surrounding Boldin and Harrison.

Answer 7

That'ss a tough one i would say the first one