Who would make a better fantasy football starting quarterback?

Question

1) Chad Pennington

2) Jason Campbell

3) Tavaris Jackson

Answer 1

None of the above.

Pennington is an injury waiting to happen.  Campbell and Jackson are both young and still very inconsistent.  But, if you were going to force me to decide, I'd go with Campbell.

Answer 2

Chad Pennington should be the better of those 3 as he is the most accurate. Campbell is gonna be decent if washington can ever grab a star WR, and with tavaris, he is still fairly inexperienced and you can expect adrian peterson to take the blunt of the offense this year.

I say pennington, because the dolphins run game is still suspect, and as a jets fan I know what he is capable of, especially if he's motivated. If you can't go with him, tavaris would be the second choice, at least they now have bernard berrien, he's a decent WR. I would put campbell 3rd on this list.  

Answer 3

if you're stuck starting one of them you're in deep trouble. there's no way unless it's like an 18 team draft you'd get stuck with one of these bums. however, tarvaris jackson has the best receiving options, and the best o-line of the 3. pennington has the most experience, but he throws the ball like a marshmallow and doesn't have good receivers and only a decent o-line. campbell is not really a cut above either. he's serviceable as a qb and not really a good fantasy start.

Answer 4

Jason Campbell for sure!

They drafted Devin Thomas, Malcolm Kelly and Fred Davis specifically to help him in passing.

Jim Zorn, their new coach, loves to pass.

Answer 5

i would normally say jason cambell, but in week one he'll have to work around the giants offense, and travaris jackson has to play against the torn up Packers. I'd go with jackson.

Answer 6

i would go campbell...

The Vikes are going to rely on Defense, and their running game. Jackson will be uselss as a fantasy QB. Pennington is not good, and he is on a very bad team.

So Campbell is probably the best of the group. Decent team and decent arm. But he too isnt a great fantasy Qb.

Answer 7

Pennington 2 years ago he was comeback player of the year.  Jets fell apart last year.  NO O-Line or running game.  This year Pennington will have two solid running backs and works real well with the playaction pass.  If possible,  Kurt Warner is a good pick up if available.  He threw for 21 touchdowns in the last 8 games he started.  and you can probably take a chance on that O'Sullivan guy in Mike Martz's offense.  

Answer 8

well if thats ur only choices, it has to be chad, the other too arent worth a dime, they like to run too much, dont throw well, dont have great receivers , and are a injury risk becuase they would rather run...like vince young ..

Answer 9

Geez, try an trade for a better QB. but if i had to pick one, id go with Chad Pennington. If you think The phins are goin to put all the pressure on ronnie brown who is fresh off of an injury season, your wrong. Plus the big tuna is there. I know he says that he will be hands off in games, but the mans a control freak, he already has that coaches game plan drawn up, and he worked with Chad in NY before. Minnesota is a AP and Chester show. Cambell is decent, but he has alot to prove before id pick him up. At least Chad has a track record of throwing the football. And with the Wideout speed he has, expect short routes but lots of yards, i hope. Cambel and chad are a gamble, i think jackson would be a mistake, but he might surprise but i wouldnt take him. good luck w ur season.

Answer 10

Jason Campbell. Pennington is too injury prone and Jackson ahs shown nothing thus far.

Answer 11

Campbell has more options

Penningtion is good when not hurt