Who would win.....Venom or Carnage?

Question

I know that venom is violent and carnage is just plain crazy, so in your opinion who would win and why

Answer 1

carnage has beat venom on two occasions but venom was at a disadvantage on both of them the only time venom beat carnage it was on an even grounds and vemon completely tore carnage's ***

i mean venom was tearing ***

complete defeat for carnage

so i say vemon would win

Answer 2

Well, this would really depend on the versions of each character you used.  If you were using the originals, Carnage has definite advantages.  For one, he's stronger than both Spider-Man & Venom put together.  Carnage is also more resistant to sonics than Venom, though he is weaker against fire.  Finally, Cletus Casady's sociopathic mind also gives him an advantage, because while Eddie Brock won't harm those he deems innocent, Casady would kill his own mother.  In fact, I think he did.  He's so crazy, when he teamed with the Joker in a crossover, the Joker was actually scared of him.

That said, I couldn't really pit modern versions against one another at this time, as Carnage is believed to have been destroyed by Sentry.  However, it would be interesting to see how the new Venom would fare against Carnage.  I'm not a big fan of this new Venom, as I prefer Mac Gargan as Scorpion & want to see Brock regain the symbiote.  I also don't like the way the new Venom is drawn.  However, I believe this Venom would have to be stronger since the host is stronger.  Likely faster, as well.  So, the Scorpion Venom version would likely be at least as strong as Carnage, & is far more experienced as a villain.  I believe this one could easily go either way, & would be interested to see if Brock retained the power boosts the symbiote gained from Scorpion if he regained the symbiote.

Answer 3

it could be a draw game, because both are symbiotic, but Spiderman can beat them*

Answer 4

Venom because he is alien with powers.

Answer 5

Venom