Who would win in a NHL fight?

Question

Sidney Crosby or Evgni Malkin? They're both mama's boys and they both have smooth skin for some reason(they didnt hit full puberty yet lol).

Tie Domi vs. Ray Emery?

Answer 1

Malkin. I dunno if you've noticed, but recently Malkin hasn't been skating away from scrums. Little Malkie is growing up before our eyess...

Domi. Emery's a loser.

Answer 2

Experience in fighting on skates is everything.

Crosby has been on super-star status in Canada since he hit puberty.  Every team he has played against in the past 8 years has likely attempted to target him... we know this is true in the QMJHL.  I would expect him to have had numerous fights and yet I have never heard of him getting beaten to a pulp...  Malkin may have been a superstar in Russia but fighting is far less of a tactic there.  So, give the significant edge to Crosby.

  The same applies to Domi and Emery.  I do hear that Emery fought a lot in the lower tiers of pro-hockey, and often there are exceptional fighters in these leagues.  However, Domi has gone toe-to-toe with the likes of Probert, Laracque, Worrell, etc etc... Now, assuming that the age difference is taken into consideration, I think Domi would win... I do think that Emery would put up more of a fight than Malkin would in the previous comparison, but Domi was an excellent fighter despite the size he gave away to most of the people he fought... here's saying that Domi would be the Ottawa Contract out of Emery!  ;-)

Answer 3

malkin, crosby may be hot, but malkins got more power :-)

Answer 4

well crosby is tougher, domi would probably knock emery on his but. what about but-***-tuzzi,has he ever fought....i cant remember any.... you.

Answer 5

Ray Emery

Answer 6

Who cares about Crosby/Malkin.  They can fight over who's gonna have the bigger paycheck in a year.

I'd love to see Domi kick Emery's butt.  Emery would give up halfway (kinda like he did in the season)

Answer 7

i think malkin would win just because he is bigger and stronger. domi would beat emery just because he is so crazy

Answer 8

Malkin, but Crosby's more of a fighter

Domi.  Emery would start whining half way through that he didn't get to start the fight.

Answer 9

1.  I have no idea- I cant picture either of them fighting.

2. Domi.  I used to call him a pit-bull!

Answer 10

Crosby is still a little boy and would probably cheat and win the fight

even though i say that i still love him and he is so cute and pretty close to my age

Answer 11

Crosby's playoff beard looks funny. How long has he been growing it for?

Answer 12

Malkin

Domi

Answer 13

Malkin,he is always in a scrum or the one starting the scrum.

That is a toughy....i'll go with Domi in his prime.

Answer 14

Malkin but Crosby did do very well against ference!

Domi no doubt about it!

Answer 15

Malkin. Crosby is a tough kid but Malkin is a pretty big guy and can throw around his wait. I wouldn't be surprised if he was good at throwing punches at well.

Domi. Experienced fighter can beat up a one timer heavy weight champ. Emery may have went 2-0 against Buffalo but Domi probably has 100 times that in wins. Old Domi would win easily but current Domi (old and retired) may have some difficulty.

Answer 16

Malkin would win.

It'd be like Godzilla breaking a toothpick

Answer 17

Malkin & Domi

Answer 18

evgani malkin. he is bigger and deffinitely would dominate over crosby in a fight.

Answer 19

Neither would win, they would stop fighting and start making wild Russian on Canadian, man love.

And Emery would just put a cap in Domi's @ss.

Answer 20

Ray

Answer 21

Crosby demo'd Ference early this year

if emery isnt in goalie equipment, ill give the edge to Razor