Who would win in a battle of the cards, yugioh or magic?

Question

Who would win in a battle of the cards, yugioh or magic?

Answer 1

Yu-Gi-Oh all the way!

Magic is for noobs!

Answer 2

It would be yugioh

Answer 3

Yu Gi Oh and Magic have different sets of rules. Making them do battle to each other won't give a result on a winner and a loser. Perhaps you're trying to say "Which is more popular: YGO or Magic?".

I'd say Yu Gi Oh; check the questions here in Yahoo! Answers card game section. If you'll notice, we have almost 10 questions about Yu Gi Oh a day in contrast to 2-3 questions about Magic daily.

Answer 4

Magic the Gathering has been around for 15 years.  It has seen the rise and fall of most every card game.  It has lasted through all the games that try to take it's thrown.

But if you are talking strength of the cards alone, Yugioh will take the cake because the simpliest 1 star creature (except those that have defense of 0) can take out any Magic creature.  Come on.  Unless you are using an ultra fast combo, how are you supposed to use your creature (16/16, the highest I can think of) to take out a monster (100/100)?  That's so stupid.  Is it because the more numbers you throw on a monster makes it anymore powerful?  If you add two 0's at the end of every magic card (creature or anything that deals damage) would that make it more appealing?  Is there a difference between Magic and Yugioh if in YGO, you started at 80 life and had the monsters drop two 0's in their attack and defense?  I think that YGO just added those 0's to make it look more powerful when in actuality, they do the same things.

Answer 5

Dude, pokemon takes the cake

Answer 6

It'll always be Yu-Gi-Oh.  Magic is old and I never see anyone even play it.

Answer 7

magic fo shizzle

Answer 8

Yu-gi-oh.

Cause they don't have cult-like obsessed people following it.