Who would win in a fight. The whole Star Trek Federation or Star wars Republic and its Rebels.?

Question

Who would win in a fight. The whole Star Trek Federation or Star wars Republic and its Rebels.?

Answer 1

I love this question.  I have been thinking about it for 20 minutes, and I keep going back and forth.  I don't know though - I kind of feel safer with the Federation.  They have more backup.  LOL

Answer 2

Federation, Republic fights with lasers and that would not effect the Enterprise's deflector shields.

Answer 3

it's not really fair... star wars just totally ignores all laws of physics and just pulls things out it's *ss...

I mean... death star destroyed a planet... that's pretty huge firepower... but it doesn't really say how? it's just a big friggin lazer?

Star trek has probably less firepower... but relatively, it's more realistic...

*dorkiest conversation of all time*

Answer 4

The Star war.

Luke against Darth Vader?

Luke 8.10,17

What do you think?

Answer 5

the federation

Answer 6

Star wars would pwn the federation.  The federation controls ~150 planets, the republic/empire controls MILLIONS.  The empire was able to blow up an asteroid with one light hit when the Enterprise D would have to use up most of its photons to blow up a HOLLOW asteroid.  Also, Voyager would take DECADES to move through one QUADRANT of the galaxy, where as star wars crosses their entire galaxy in AT MOST DAYS.  Check out www.stardestroyer.net for a full argument, but it is quite obvious that the federation would be squashed under the star wars galaxy's heel.  (which is logical given SW republic existed as a spacefaring society for 25,000+ years compared to what, 200-300 years of the federation?)

To the above answerer>  Thousands of planets in several galaxys?  you must be joking!  The federation has never left one QUADRANT of one galaxy!  Picard estimated only 150 planets in the federation, and the scope of the organization supports it!

Answer 7

Federation. Especially after their upgrade for a Borg invasion. They have shields and targeting systems. Federation would destroy them.

Answer 8

Neither... it would be a draw until Jack O'Neill and SG-1 gated in and took them all out with witty repartee.

Answer 9

Star Trek. Not only do they have the Federation which consists of thousands of planets spanning several galaxies,they have the borg which adapt to anything and can assimilate the jedi(Borg Jedi imagine that) Forget the fact that they also have the Q who are a race of all powerful omnipitant god like beings that live for eternity and never die and can do anything they desire including alter the future and the past.    Its common knowledge that some one in Star Trek always travels back in time to change an important historical event wether on purpose or accident so if they did lose it would all be changed.

Answer 10

I have to side with the Federation.