Who would you choose between THESE 2 Great QB's: A primed Terry Bradshaw or a primed Troy Aikman?

Question

Who would you choose between THESE 2 Great QB's: A primed Terry Bradshaw or a primed Troy Aikman?

Answer 1

Aikman

Answer 2

This is a tough question because both performed so well in different offensive schemes.

Would Bradshaw excel in the Cowboys' 1990's precision, timing-based passing game?

Would Aikman excel in the Steelers's wide open attack tossing it deep all the time to Swann and Stallworth?

I'm not sure on either. Aikman was the far more accurate passer, so I would lean in that direction. But I don't want to take anything away from what Bradshaw achieved by saying this.

Answer 3

Bradshaw in his prime, easily.

Answer 4

who cares. Its more about you isnt it.

Answer 5

I'd go with Aikman.

Bradshaw as a good QB, but he needed help from the officiating crew and luck on way too many occasions.  

Yeah, I know I will catch alot of flack for saying that, but it is the truth.

Everyone knows the officiating assistance the Steelers got in the Super Bowl against Dallas. The NFL even issued a statement saying that the call for pass interference was wrong.

'Immaculate Reception'????? More of a fluke, not the product of preordination by a higher power.  

Answer 6

joe montana better than them both

Answer 7

Aikman is one of the most under rated QB's ever, he was one of the most accurate QB's ever and his numbers weren't great because they were an all rounded team.

I'd still take Bradshaw in his prime because Aikman's mobility was well... he didn't have any.

Answer 8

Hey Kei you are thinking of BEN having the worst QB rating by a QB in the Superbowl(and I think that goes winning and losing) NOT Bradshaw. Maybe in his time Bradshaw had one, but remember how few Superbowls there were and how many he was the winner. His last was like Superbowl 12, and that means there were only 8 he didn't win up to that point.

Anyway I'd clearly take Bradshaw over Aikman. Then again I'm also a Steelers fan.  

Answer 9

Troy Aikman.

Answer 10

For one thing without Lynn Swann Bradshaw would never had did what he did.As far as Troy goes I think there is a better selection out there,at least somebody who is going to play for more than 3 years!!!!!!!!

Answer 11

Bradshaw, hands down! Aikman, though having to anchor a team that was out of control, was not as great and gritty as Terry Bradshaw.

Aikman was also too injuring prone, while Bradshaw was like a punching bag; always a football player 1st!

Answer 12

I'd take Aikman. Bradshaw has the worst QB rating ever by a winning superbowl QB in one of his Superbowl wins. That only proves that defense wins championships and his did just that.

Answer 13

Bradshaw narrowly.

Answer 14

Wow...two hall of famers to choose from.  They are both equally good but I think I would have to go with Bradshaw because he led those dominant Steelers teams in the 70s.  BTW:  from looking at your avatar pic, you're a hottie.  Take care.

Answer 15

Brett Favre