Who would you draft: Roy Williams or Calvin Johnson?

Question

If I have to choose between Roy Williams or Calvin Johnson when drafting, who would you choose? Williams is still pretty young, but it looks like Johnson could surpass him as a better fantasy WR this year. They seem too close to call.

Answer 1

I have to go with Calvin Johnson due to Roy Williams being such a stud.   In Detroit's scheme, Williams is going to draw double coverage and leave Johnson more open.  With his athletic ability, he's going to perform.  Good luck with your pick.

Answer 2

If i were you i wouldn't take either one because they split time, but if you have to pick one I would take Calvin Johnson because he's #2 on the depth chart so he will usually be guarded by the #2 CB and the lions schedule doesn't face alot of good cbs  

Answer 3

I think Calvin Johnson will have a good year this year.  I'd pick him.

Answer 4

calvin because of his raw talent should be a no-brainer

Answer 5

Williams has more experience but i'll take Johnson because he has such raw talent even after one year. I'm sure in a few years he will be a star

Answer 6

I think Calvin will have a breakout year.

Answer 7

I would pick Roy Williams for 3 reasons:

1. He is a proven WR, Calvin Johnson is not.

2. Calvin is injury prone, more so than williams

3. Williams played 5 mins last night and had 50 yards and a TD, Calvin played 12 mins and had 36 yds and 0 TDs