Who would you keep if you could only keep one?

Question

Reggie Wayne or Braylon Edwards

Answer 1

Wayne, only because Manning has shown that wayne is basically his number one target. Edwards still has to prove himself, and derek anderson has to prove himself that he can be consitent. After saying all of that, it's a very close decision. Flip a coin if u have to.

Answer 2

Reggie Wayne, no question, since he has a better QB.

Answer 3

Baylon hes go more potential

Answer 4

Reggie Wayne.   though im anxious to see how healthy Peyton is at the beginning of the year (course DA did just get banged up himself)

Answer 5

Reggie Wayne

Answer 6

Reggie Wayne!!!! Other than the fact that he's from ( THE U ) Check it out.  Wayne has Peyton as QB and Marvin Harrison has been plagued with that injury all last year and it hasn't got any better.... Edwards has Anderson as QB if he comes back from that concussion he received last game... If not you have Quinn with needs more time to be a NFL caliber QB , that means he'll be dumping off to Winslow more that anyone!!!!!!