Who would you rather give up for Johan Santatna??

Question

I have a guy that said he would take either Oswalt or Harden for Johan. Which of the 2 would you rather give to get Johan??

Answer 1

Im not a big fan of Oswalt, Harden however had dominated the NL, oppents are batting under 200. So if i had to I'd take Harden.

Answer 2

It would be a really stupid move on your part if you gave him Rich Harden. He has been healthy this year and has really domintaed, while Oswalt on the other hand has really sucked it up in Houston. Harden was traded today to the Cubs, and this is how I see it.....It is very unlikely that the Astros will make the playoffs, and the Cubs are trying to win their division. Lou Piniella is really counting on Harden to be a strong number 3 guy in their rotation. So, I say DO NOT trade Harden away for anyone...hold onto him, he is awesome this year and is going to get even hotter!