Who would you rather have on your team: Roy Halladay or Brandon Webb?

Question

Please Star

Answer 1

I think Webb is a better pitcher than Halladay but Halladay is great. I think someone you really have to think about is Joba Chamberlain. He is younger and in the future he could be as good as they are now. I say if you want to win now Webb is the best but Joba is probably the best to have.

Answer 2

Easily Brandon Webb, he kills the Dodgers every time.  

Answer 3

Brandon Webb why because he has had the best season now roy halladay is doing great but brndon webb is having an amazing seasson not only in the pitching but in the batting to he has had like seaven rbi's i think peace

Answer 4

Both are good but right now i would go more for Halladay.

Answer 5

I want Halladay :)

Answer 6

Halladay easily... more complete innings and he's in the AL East, probably the most toughest division in baseball:

Rays, Red Sox, Yankees..

Answer 7

Brandon Webb Because he is more relaible.

Answer 8

hallady no doubt he should go to nats and help us out.

Answer 9

Roy Halladay no doubt, alot of his losses this year was because his offense couldn't produce. He would go 7-9 innings and only allow 2 runs, and he would take the loss. He has more complete games then anyone and he also has to pitch in a tougher division.

Why would someone mention Joba Chamberlain in this question? Friggin stupid.

Answer 10

Hands down, Halladay.

Answer 11

brandon webb. they are both great pitchers that have filthy stuff, but i guess it comes down to who you think can do it for the most years.. and thats webb

Answer 12

I would say Halladay because he has a longer history of great performances on his track record.

Answer 13

Ouch, pretty tough choice. I say Holliday because of his ability to be a mule and eat up innings like there is no friggin tomorrow!

Also, check out the divisions in which each of these guys pitch in. Brandon Webb pitches to non-hitting teams like the Padres and Dodgers while Holliday has to take on the likes of David Ortiz, Alex Rodriguez, Kevin Youkilis and Derek Jeter. Big Difference.

Answer 14

Brandon Webb, for sure, i saw him pitch yesterday and evetho he had a bad outing, he still looked great .....

Answer 15

I would love to have Roy Halladay on my team!  He's one of the greatest pitchers in baseball today.

Answer 16

Roy Halladay. Not only is he (in my opinion( the best pitcher in baseball, but he's on my Fantasy team and a personal favorite of mine. he appeals to logos and ethos. ha.

Answer 17

without a doubt halladay, no one can go all 9 as much as he can. Many times the game is over before it begins if he's on.

Answer 18

i would pick Brandon Webb

Answer 19

PINSTRIPES YOU COPIED MY IDEA!! :( haha i would take brandon webb.

EDIT: Haha yeah, its cool i dont mind.

Answer 20

wow this is a really tough one...i am of the opinion that brandon webb is the best pitcher in baseball, but halladay is really underrated because he pitches for a blue jays team that hasn't been in the race at any point...i think webb has put up some slightly better numbers more consistently over time so i would give him the slight nod, but halladay definitely doesn't get the respect he deserves

Answer 21

roy halladay... no question