Who would you rather if you could chose only one; Franklin OR Ablett OR Bartel?

Question

I would have to go with Ablett, hes more experienced and more consistent Although Buddy is on fire lately and we all know how good Bartel is.

Its really hard to make a decision, they are all top players!

Anyway what are your thoughts?

Answer 1

Buddy for sure

Answer 2

as a tiger fan this q is close to my heart

in hindsite the tigers should have taken buddy but hindsite is a great thing

midfielders are a dime a dozen but forwards like franklin are few and far between

however alas we picked tambling over him cos at that time thats what we needed and i have no regrets as he can become a gun and im sure he will

but my vote for this goes to buddy

Answer 3

Bartel.

Answer 4

Im going for Bartel. hes awesome.

Answer 5

Garry Ablet

Answer 6

id  say bartel, hes won brownlow and aint too bad this year, ablett... i dunno i jus dunt like the guy an u gotta give franklin a couple of years b4 he becomes a great

Answer 7

Bartel is way up there on both of them. he is hot!!!! and geelong could not be geelong without him. he is one of the best i have seen and he can do about anything. So go Bartel!

Answer 8

Franklin - because he is a West Austraian - plus the other two are big sooks.

Answer 9

Yes Gary Ablett for me at this point in time.  Buddy has been slightly inconsistent and Jimmy hasn't played to his capabilities as yet.  This all may change in a month or two.

Answer 10

Hm... tough question.

Bartel : He is the king in midfield. Without him, Geelong's possession will not be this superb.

Ablett : No question he is a genius. He can pass to ball to anywhere.

Buddy : The most dangerous forward. He can always find an empty spot to get the marks.

I'll  go for Bartel. Because... no possession -> no attack -< lose.

Answer 11

Buddy Franklin

Answer 12

Buddy rules........and im not even a hawks supporter

Answer 13

#1- Buddy

#2- Bartel

#3- Ablett

Answer 14

None of them.

If I had the choice of being someone else it would be the likes of Bill Gates, or someone with his kind of money.

Answer 15

buddy by far

there are so many midfielders

Answer 16

Franklin

west coast teams must be kicking them self's

brainiacs

Answer 17

bartel

Answer 18

Buddy by far cause hes been on fire yet ablett and bartel have benn playin solidably buddys been on fire so i have to say buddy

Answer 19

i would have to chose buddy franklin as he is a supperstar up forward and is only at the age of 21 and has a huge future ahead of him...

Answer 20

neither..........ryan o'keefe VERY underrated

Answer 21

Would have to be Ablett. Forwards kick goals and miss goals and are rarely consistent. Beside from top marks and long bombs Franklin doesn't do much and will be worked out soon enough. Ablett has far more rounded skills...he can create and kick goals..much more valuable...plus simply having Ablett blood makes him more valuable...we all know what that gene pool has done

Answer 22

Of course Franklin hes quick, smart and can kick goals

Answer 23

Buddy Franklin. He kicks more goals. Bartel and Ablett set up goals but others can do the same. Ablett is injured at the moment and Bartel has been quiet.

Answer 24

With Hall out at the moment Swans could sure use a target like Franklin right now so I'll say Buddy!

Answer 25

Ablett is a proven champ, Bartel has won a brownlow, buddy is on the way up, with a bullet, but i would still take Ablett, he produces great games every week, whist buddy is hit or miss, 1.7 ain't good footy in my books.

Answer 26

Ablett

he's pretty darn cool