Who would you start Week 1 as your QB and why?

Question

I went with the "get 2-3 QBs late" draft strategy and have Eli Manning (Home vs Was), David Garrard (@ Ten) and Kurt Warner (@ San Fran). Who would you start Week 1? I'm not looking for who will be the best QB by the end of the season, just who will put up the most points the first week.

Answer 1

I would go with Garrard

Answer 2

Tough call...SF has a worse pass defense than either Ten or Was though al three are in the top half of the league.  Go with Eli.  He's at home and maybe the end of last season is a portend to home he will start this year.

Answer 3

kurt Warner. experiance beats skill

Answer 4

Warner...he's an early season warrior with a good matchup.  Eli is solid and will probably be your best performer of the longhaul and Garrard never turns the ball over, but usually doesn't put up big numbers either.