Who would you take 3rd overall?

Question

Tomlinson went first. Peterson second. Then I took Moss. I know it was a bit early but I wanted him and knew he wouldn't come back around.

Answer 1

I would have taken Brady (if it was 20 yards per point and 6 points per touchdown pass) or Brian Westbrook.  I think that Moss was a little soon and you could have tried to trade for him by doing a multiple guy trade from both sides.

BK

Answer 2

You have to take Westbrook there, what does the rest of your team look like?  I am sure you are hurting now especially drafting that early because you have to wait a while to draft again and by then most of the good players are gone.  I am suggesting not taking Brady any earlier then 10th or 11th.  That way you can come right back in round 2 and grab a decent RB.  Where you drafted your getting a medium to low end 1RB and a low end 2RB not to mention weaker WR's.  Check out my site and send me an email with your entire team and I will evaluate it for you.  I may even use it on my blog cause its an interesting situation.

Answer 3

You should have taken Jackson, Addai or Westbrook.

Answer 4

Moss mark....spare

Answer 5

I would have taken Westbrook

Answer 6

In that case I would have taken Westbrook, because not only does he get good rushing yards & td's, but he has also been one of the best running backs who can catch. His receiving yards do nothing but add to his numbers. Only downside is injury, but that could still happen to anyone....

Answer 7

I would take Westbrook #2 so I would be happy if he fell to three

Answer 8

I probably would have gone with Joseph Addai.  He's going to be a 1500 yd rusher and he'll be among the top 3 in rushing TDs.  I also expect him to get a little extra work the first couple weeks of the season as they try to get Manning back into the swing of things.