Whos the better man united centre back?

Question

me and my 2 lads were having this discussion earlier and couldn't agree,so we have decided to put it to the vote,is it vidic or big rio,i personally think vidic he also reminds me of jaap stam.

Answer 1

Having just seen Man Utd vs Newcastle Utd on Spanish TV I would say Vidic. I have been a Newcastle fan for over 60 years.

Answer 2

vidic, ma best m8

Answer 3

Well both are really great players. Made a unstoppable team together last season and hopefully will this season. I'd say both are equal.

Answer 4

BIG rio?

Answer 5

i will go for Vidic

Answer 6

Neither are world class, but they do have a fantastic partnership and understanding that makes them a world class pair when together. Both have very even ability but I'd go with Vidic personally. Simply because he hasn't put a foot wrong since the start of his Man United career whilst Rio has been prone to error on a number of occasions.

Answer 7

vidic defo

Answer 8

easy big rio.......

Answer 9

Nemanja Vidic. What a fantastic signing.