Why are some people unsatisfied with breaking dawn?

Question

the last book in the twilight saries.

i enjoyed it but some people i hear didn't and i wanna know why.

Answer 1

i think it has to do with the fact that nobody died or that the ending was to cliche or somthing like that. But i personaly loved it!

:D

Answer 2

i agree with DANCE UR HEART about the s*x thing, also i was like everything went to perfect for them after the birth of renesmee. and then the ending was very predictable, which by the way didnt really give me a good sense of closure. Anyways, thats just my opinion of why it didnt satisfy me.

Answer 3

I think the reason a lot of people didn't like the book was that the climax fell a little flat

(Spoiler Alert*******)  

I like the idea that the Cullens are "superheros" -- to use Stephenie Meyer's words.  I wanted them to vanquish the foe (the Volturi), but they did not.  The Volturi simply said, "ooooooo.  We're scared.  I think we'll go home now and forget that this ever happened."  

There needed to be some show of real force --- and the Cullens needed to rise to the occasion, taking on the evil and overcoming them  -------- not necessarily killing all the Volturi, but they needed to incapacitate them by taking out key members instead of leaving them to do the same evil.  The only difference is that now, all the Cullens' friends expect to be taken out one by one.  That's not the way a superhero would leave things.

Answer 4

I think some people had a long time to wait between Eclipse and Breaking Dawn so they imagined what could happen in BD and made a lot of predicitons which created this stroy in their minds that they were hoping for... then when the book came out they were disappointed because they expected something much more different

just my opinion but i personally LOVED it !

Answer 5

i like it fine. it is a great book and sums everything up. i just want to know with leah, what happnes to her. and jacob and nessie. but i heard that SM is going to write a twilight for jacob and nessie. but i dont know, and from brees pov, and from edwards, and jasper and alices story of how they met, that will be fun...

Answer 6

i loved it but my friends were disappointedd because somethings she left you hanging. and the ending it was happy but too soon

Answer 7

i think because it switched up everything.

it was soo different from what people expected it to be so they didnt like it.

plus bella has responsibilities now and it took away the "carefree strictly true love" feel of the book.

but after reading it three times, ive grown to love it.  

Answer 8

i absolutely loved the book. edward and bella deserved to be happy after all they went through. i know alot of people i talked to were upset that she was a "good" vampire so fast. they wanted her to struggle like jasper. i think that too make the book have a quicker pace she needed to be controlled right away. i do want to know what happened with renesmee and jacob though. i also cant wait for edward's point of veiw, midnight sun.

Answer 9

well i thought it was OK   but the reason some people might be disatisfied is because well first off the s*x thing...i mean it was ok the first time but then it was kinda all the ever did for alot of the book, well they did other stuff but everything ended up ending with that. i thought it kinda ruined there relationship a bit because b4 they loved eachother soo much without that. and thats what i liked. it proved that that doesnt have to be part of a relationship. another reason may be because near the end of the book it kinda seemed like the author was just trying to wrap it up and finish it so i think she mad bellas "power" work a little to easily to her advantage.

Answer 10

I think i was disappointed because it had been so antisipated and the ending wa sso predicatable and i just didn't think it was what people wanted.

SM might as well have wrote 'and Bella woke up as it was all a dream' because i just think the book could have been so much better.