Why do New zealand and Australria not choose players who play their club rugby abroad?

Question

Is this an actual rule and if it is who enforces it?

What would happen if the coach picked someone based in europe?

Do South Africa have a similar rule?

Answer 1

I think they just dont like people playng else where and then try to get into the All BLAck sqaud...

If any one plays in another country ...he will not be likeable to be chosen for the All Blacks.

ANother thing is that the All Blacks have os many players in and around New Zeeland ...the dont bother with others not "being there"

South Africa chose J vd Westhuizen for the SPringboks but he played in JApan Club rugby.... This alone caused a lot of arguments in SA as they feel the players in the CurrieCup and Super 14 are more than enough to choose from.

THe Ausssies wanted MAtt Burke to come back and play for their Squad in this years world cup...he declined.

Answer 2

its not a rule, its a policy, going and playing abroad is considered turning one's back on New Zealand, that might as well be your resignation.