Why do they let pedophiles back into the public domain?

Question

Surly they could find an island somewhere and let them live there.Instead of letting them loose to terrorise the streets,rehabilitation isn't the answer so what is?

Answer 1

100% agree.

Answer 2

If it is accepted that g*y people can not help being g*y, there is no treatment and no cure, then we should accept that peodophiles can not be cured. They should be held indefinately under the mental health act and should never see the light of day. There is no other way of keeping our society safe. I find it interesting that women are often held for life under the mental health act for far less serious crimes, whilst men are deemed to be in their right mind and yet are set free to commit more serious crime.  

Answer 3

No good society would do that.  You have to give people a chance.  Sentencing guidelines for offenses are in place, and they don't call for banishment to some isle of the pedophiles.

What is the answer?  That's a great question.  The cause of pedophilia isn't even totally understood.

Answer 4

If you make the sentences harsher (death, life in prison, exile etc) then the pedophile no longer has an incentive to keep his victim alive. Killing the victim removes a witness.

Answer 5

Because there is a law called "Cruel and Unusual Punishment". Believe it or not, a majority of convicted pedophiles do not reoffend. Once in a while, you'll see it in the news but most of them do not have priors.

If you think that putting them on some island is going to stop child molestation from happening, you're dead wrong. There are pedophiles in society that have not been convicted of it, and have not been turned in. Most pedophiles only make the offense once, so unless you read minds, this idea you have won't solve the problem of protecting our children.

Not to mention, a majority of pedophiles molested someone they knew whether it was a family member or friend of the family.

Answer 6

I think castration is the anwer, personally. And I am VERY serious

Answer 7

Apparently, cuz we can't shoot them.

Answer 8

doesn't make sence does it.  I agree with you.

Answer 9

We seem to have become a country who thinks the criminals have more rights.  Recently in Massachusetts a father caught a guy touching his young son in the men's room of a store.  The father punched the guy (and I say good for him) but he was also arrested for assault.  Funny thing is that the father showed up for the court date but the predator didn't.  He was an illegal and went back home instead.  We need to start giving more rights to the honest citizens.  

It would be great to be able to drop them all off on an island but then that would be cruelty and we can't do that.  Remember "they have rights."

Answer 10

we don't try to rehabilitate anyone in America.

You can't deport an American citizen.

Answer 11

Because bleeding heart liberals wrote the sentencing guidelines.

You get what you vote for in this country.

Answer 12

yes and put the junkies and murder's on the same small island, what about anthrax island

Answer 13

otherwise it violates their human rights.

Answer 14

Which Island where you thinking of, Man or Wight?  Or perhaps Anglesey?  Or Egg?  

Answer 15

if you deport all of your criminals to an island, they will come back in a couple of decades and thrash you at rugby, cricket, and aussie rules football.  

Answer 16

Put them on the island like you say.  Then infest the island with a bug that crawls into all orifices and lays eggs and eats tissue and let them die a slow and painful death.

Answer 17

Having "robbed the innocence of these Kids" The Law Says  Naughty you need to get locked up then they let "Kiddy Fiddlers" back into the public domain To me personnally I have a Problem With The Punishment. Some of these Kids Are Scarred For Life Because of these Monsters Actions If you killed a kid you get life But if you Scar a kid For life they lock you up for a bit These"kiddy Fiddlers" need to be  Known to the Public No "If's or Buts"We Should as protecters of our children have the write to know who they Are now not tomorrow next year Because they Are Worst than Terrorists as far as im Concerned  SAILOR "they have rights." they also had a right to leave the kid alone

Answer 18

they should all be executed  

Answer 19

You could try Manhattan, but they filled that island up with the homosexuals.  

Answer 20

Hi Matthew B,

Our criminal justice system sucks enough said at least in the USA.    Drugs & more drugs to make them totally unconsicus. Rehabilation--chop off his p***s,  hands, feet. same for women-period  then send them to any island we can find.  Have a good night. :0)

Additional Details: all woman should carry a hat pin ( a good weapon) & pepper spray.

Answer 21

Sorry...even though there is all the documented proof in the world that says they cannot be rehabilitated, the liberals pay no attention to it.  After all what do facts and bleeding hearts have to do with each other?