Why mud crab is not consider Haram/illicit. Given that this crab live in 2 world?

Question

to zack So why can't Muslim eat frog because it lives in the water and on the land. Mud crab is a creature that live in mangrove not sea

Answer 1

Excuse my ignorance, where do we find "ayah" or "ahadeeth" that said creature that live in 2 worlds are haraam.

What is meant by 2 worlds?

I have been eating any living things out of the sea all my life. This is rather strange to me.

Do I need to "taubat"

Answer 2

Those crabs actually live in water most of the time. They eat in water, they mate in water and they lay their eggs in water. They don't ever need to come out of water. Yes.. I know they can live a long time when taken out of water but eventually they will die without it.

But, do ask the learned.

Answer 3

OK, It's either I drank too much ..water.

Or your question doesn't make sense!

Frogs are cute though.. I'd never want to eat them

Answer 4

Basically its is a water crab, comes out and stays in mud too sometimes, it is not haram,   its yummy.

Answer 5

ANY KIND OF CRAB IS NOT HALAL   IT HAS NO FINS OR SCALES LIKE FISH    ANY WATER CREATURE MUST HAVE FINS OR SCALES   AND CANT DIE OF ITS SELF  MEANING IT MUST BE ALIVE WHEN YOU CATCH IT    

Answer 6

go to askimam.org and ask this question i am not sure what mud crab is

Answer 7

cuz its not ;)

im not sure wht ur talkin about tho

Answer 8

fdvhbrfttthpiu  U understand that ???

thats how i dont understnd yours it dont make sense to me