Why was Marx wrong?? ?

Question

Amustaph: 150 years have passed by since the Manifesto.

the revolution is late.

Answer 1

he was unwilling to accept certain aspects of human nature

Answer 2

Who says Marx was wrong?  Step outside !!!!

Answer 3

There can be no entrepreneurs under Marxism.  The desire to "live well" has fueled more progress than any other social psychology.  Marxism kills that.  Marxism assumes that the "workers and laborers" provide all of the value.  That's simply untrue.  Works and laborers paired with industrial visionaries are the ones that make great things happen.

Answer 4

It is impossible to put anyone in a complete position of power and expect them to not become corrupted by it.  Communism does not work, socialism does not work

People must be self reliant and not reliant upon the government for hand outs

Answer 5

His analysis was flawed Therefore the predictions he made were also flawed.He based his various theories on what he saw happening in Victorian capitalism.From that ( he thought ) he recognised something in history which he called "dialectical materialism" : a process which he believed accounted for all political & economic change up to his time.He then predicted this process would continue into the future and (almost inevitably) evolve into communism.Predicting the future is a tricky business.  

Answer 6

The difference between anarchy and social order is never more clear when Governments break their own laws.

The reason Marxism fails is not because of poor leadership or the corruption of power but the absence of a system of public consent protected by law that is internationally recognised as sacrosanct.

A system of public consultation that has evolved from old feudal methods of control still influence the framework in which contemporary political solutions are sought after. I have yet to absorb some of Monbiot's ideas about  a radical reformation of consensual politics that avoids the common mistakes made by past ideological tyrants.

This topic is a public debate that touches the hearts and minds of the poor and oppressed in every nation. It has a massive forum and Government operators are keeping a close watch on how it develops into activist groups. They should be getting the message by now, the public are tired of the present arcane system of representation.

Answer 7

Because it's human nature to create your own little space, instead of living in the space another dictates for you, whethere another is 1 or 100.

Answer 8

Marx wasnt wrong. Lenin did when he introduced Stalin to the soviet union and when stalin this his own ideology.

Soviet Union felt because of stalins oppression. Cuba has also a stalinist ideology but also a new ideology thats why cuba its pretty well in its economy and their people.

Communist 4 life.

Answer 9

Because he assumed that history was predetermined and that capitalism would inevitably collapse and be replaced by Communism. Hasn't happened so far and doesn't look like it's anywhere on the horizon (I mean in terms of Germany and the UK). He was right about a lot of things though but now it's all a little outdated (e.g.since then the middle classes have developed and they're not taken into account with his bourgeoisie/proletariat model). I quite like Marxism/Neo-Marxism, some of it anyway, but it's all a bit too economically deterministic for me. I need my own sociological theory where parts from different theories are all mashed together.

Answer 10

Let's ask all the little people who live in places like Cuba, the ex-Soviet Union, or China how well they live(d) under Communist rule.

Then, let's compare that to how well the leaders of those regimes lived.

Then, let's compare that to how well the friends and family of the leaders lived.

Communism is a lie!  A giant scam.

Think people!  Think!  Use your brains   Ask good questions, Then go find the answers on your own!

Answer 11

Marx was not wrong, he was actually very right in a lot of ways. It just any ism is never pure, you have to take some wisdom from each. Capitalism by definition will spend all resources of the planet and destroy the human race so there you have it