Will Favre start over Jeff Garcia?

Question

At a first glance, you guys might think I'm crazy having to asked this question when no dbout Favre is a hall of fame QB and Garcia is just a pretty good QB. Ofcourse people will start a hall of fame over a some what good QB right? Well if you think about it, there might be some friction in the Tampa Bay training camp if Favre end up being there and most likely will. Garcia played great last year especially toward the end of the season and guys began to gel with him then now a new guy (granted a hall of fame) comes in and tell the players to gel with him. I mean wouldnt that be a problem? I heard that most of the buccaneers players prefer Garcia to start over Favre because he already knows the offense and have great chemistry with the WRs. Even though Favre is a hall of famer, there is no gaurenteed he will be good with that offense. I can gaurenteed u that Garcia will be better in that offense than Favre. I believe favre is better in Minnisota than in Tampa Bay but that's just a dream scenorio for me. What do you guys think? I dont think Favre should start over Garcia even though Favre is a better QB but im sure Favre will start over Garcia.

Answer 1

That's what's kind of screwy about the Favre to Tampa Bay situation. I don't know why they would invite a QB controversey by trading for Favre (unless Garcia was traded to GB, which would still be ridiculous). In the case that Favre did end up in TB with Garcia, I would imagine that they would just compete for the job. Of course, the real deciding factor would be compatibility with receivers (Favre's rocket arm has been known to intimidate his receivers), of which I would give the edge to Jeff Garcia.

Answer 2

If he doess at least h**l still have 37 backups... Favre to Tampa is BULLLSHIT.... THEY HAVE NO RECIEVERS... 30 QBS... NOT THAT GREAT RUNNING GAME...unlike the Vikings who need him most cuzz they have no QB...

Answer 3

No one is trading for Favre to leave him on the bench. Consider Garcia done unless Favre gets hurt. Odds are Garcia gets traded.  

Answer 4

Favre has a good relationship with the coach there in TB apparently and is familiar with their system so it might not be as hard a transition as some think.

Answer 5

Lets hope so for the "BUCS" sake.

Answer 6

i think they'll probably just fight for starting position in the pre season i guess

Answer 7

i think the Bucs will also trade Favre to the Vikings i think that was one of the inncentives is that Favre goes to the Bucs keep him for 24 hrs then trade him to the Vikes thats what Farve wants hey it worked for Eli when he wanted to go to New York plus Favre has a big ego and wants to destroy the Packs for making a bad call and treating him the way they treated him Brett Favre wants to stay and compete in his own division so i think he will be wearing purple and white in 2008

Answer 8

Yes Favre will start , guess what Viking fans? The Bucs will probably trade  Garcia to the vikes or bears.