Will martin brodeur be the greatest of all time?

Question

i asked that questin becaues he is 14 wins shy of breaking the all time wins record and he will break the all time shutout record. i also better never hear that brodeur is overrated. he is not overrated and he won another vezina trophy this year. one other thing will his 90-91 score rookie card ever go up in price?

Answer 1

I agree with Mike, it's definitely a toss up between him and Roy, I'd give the advantage to Roy, but there's definitely nothing being taken away from Brodeur.

Answer 2

yes, hopefully he will overshadow everything wah did, except be a goof.

Answer 3

I think it's between him, Turco, and Osgood

Answer 4

Well, none of us can agree on who the best forward is of all time, but I think its safe to say when the arguments of who the best goalie of all time is, Brodeur will definitely be in the mix.

Answer 5

His rookie card was so mass produced

it will never be worth very much ungraded

also yes he will break both records

i have always enjoyed watching him play

never liked watching roy's temper tantrums

roy is a baby   he cried his way out of montreal

while brodeur has been a class act in new jersey

uggghhhh  jersey

Answer 6

One of the greats but not THE greatest.  Sawchuk and Roy are still ahead of Brodeur in greatness.

Answer 7

its a toss up between him and roy but i give the edge to roy he was great

Answer 8

greatest goalie maybe but not player of all time... that's saying a lot

Answer 9

It's all a matter of opinion. If you were to ask me who's the best of all time Brodeur is the first guy to pop into mind.

But then again Patrick Roy and Jacques Plante also pop right into mind.

Answer 10

No while bordeur has won 3 cups i think patrick roy was better.

Answer 11

I think he already is.  Roy was great but Brodeur is doing what he's doing in an NHL that is actively trying to increase scoring.  Brodeur is on track to break Roy's records with smaller pads, rule changes that benefit scorers, and all in a much faster NHL.  Not to mention that the Devils won't do so much as give him at least a respectable defense.  Brodeur's records will one day be broken, but until that happens he is the best goalie in National Hockey League history.

Answer 12

Definitely, I second DC Fury. He's either beaten or about to beat all Goaltender records there are. No one else other than Roy even comes close.

Answer 13

Roy is more than likely going to be known as the greatest goalie until Carey Price gets older... just kidding lol(but you never know)... Broduer will obviously go to the hall and it is impressive that at his age he can still play a good game

For your second part-er I highly doubt it. After they reach there mid-point in there career the cards usually don't change. If they do change they usually drop just because poeple lose intrest. Since Broduer is well broduer his card won't/ shouldn't change any.