Will review system make test cricket more intresting?

Question

Will review system make test cricket more intresting?

Answer 1

yes.. make it more uncontroversial

Answer 2

If umpires are insulted.... infact, when u have reviewing... why even keep an umpire... I mean yeah... but i think umpire should only be there to make only the OBVIOUS decisions.... they shouldnt go for the hard ones and they should start giving third umpire decisions even for LBW decisions..... Remember Kitply Cup final when Pak won by 25 runs... Afridi was bowling and 5 obvious LBW decisions were given not out... when all were out!!     See.. If Pakistan hadn't won that match... the Pakistanis would assault the umpire literally and physically... you know what kind of a country Pak is.... Anyways... I think review system should be there but umpires too... in that case... umpires don't get humiliated either...

Answer 3

The review system  has been experimented only in one test match so far.  One will have to wait and see how good the

system will be.

Answer 4

yes.

Answer 5

yes

Answer 6

Its fair for the playing teams..

But umpires are too much insulted. lol

Answer 7

one thing it will do is make it so andrew symonds will be out after edging the ball back to the keeper

Answer 8

I agree with one in a million, it will make cricket fair. But at the same time umpire may get humiliated or feel sad by knowing that he has made a wrong decision if his decision was wrong.

Answer 9

Should make it fairer on the whole.  However I have already seen a post in this section from some idiot accusing the TVO in the IND v SL test of taking money. You can't please some people unless their teams win despite the facts!

Answer 10

IT will make cricket much more fair!!

Answer 11

It will make test cricket at least fair.

Answer 12

I don't think so. On the contrary questionable (caused by human error) decisions give people a bit more to discuss about and fight over and that is more interesting to me than a scientific decision made on the spot. I like the human aspect in any game. We must learn to live with unfavorable decisions. Cricket is a sport and as such it should be taken as a sport and nothing more. Even in courts judges make mistakes. Are we going to implement some kind of review system there as well? If you appoint a man to do his job then learn to trust his unbiased judgments.

Answer 13

YES BUT NOT TOO MUCH .

IT CAN EVEN WORK IN ODI AND T20