Will this guy accept this trade??

Question

Im giving him Carlos Lee and Johan Santana

Im getting: Manny, and chase utely

Would this be a good trade for me? BTW i sent it, so im not sure if this guy will accept it...

My team:: (10 man league)

C B Molina

1B Pujols

2B Jose Lopez

SS Renteria

3B Wright

OF Vlad, C Lee, Bay

Util Wells

BN Giambi, Crawford

DLFurcal

SP Johan, Webb, Volquez, Bedard, Verlander, Harden

RP Valverde,Torres, Franklin

DLPercival,

Answer 1

why dont u just do the trade and see if he says yes instead of typing all of this for an opinion?

Answer 2

It depends if he really needs starting pitching.  Otherwise it's not really an overwhelming deal.  Lee and Ramirez are pretty much the same, and Utley is much better than Johan at this point.  Johan's no longer the dominant top dog, he's still one of the best tho, but Utley's the best player in fantasy right now.  I wouldn't take it

Answer 3

if he needs pitching and has a replacement for Utley he might accept it

Answer 4

he won't accept if he's smart

Answer 5

Depends who will he move in to play second base, unless I had a top 5 second basemen I would not give up Utley the position is to week and pitching can be taken care of by picking up spot starts throughout the year.

Answer 6

I would turn it down. Utleys numbers are huge.

Answer 7

I would definatley decline your trade if i were him. Lee and Ramirez are solid but Utley has been dominating in fantasy. Johan is no longer the amazing pitcher, he is good but no longer the numero uno.

Great trade for you bad trade for him.

Answer 8

Looks fair to me. Good Luck.